Distinguishing Intellectual Property Valuation (IPV) From Other Company Assets In Mergers And Acquisitions

Introduction
With the increasing desire for expansion of businesses and development in the corporate world, companies engage in highly sophisticated corporate restructuring options to remain relevant. The result of this desire has led to the increasing rate of mergers and acquisitions in today’s business trends. In some instances, mergers and acquisitions may occur when an unlisted acquirer obtains the controlling shares of a listed target and may want to continue to operate in the name of the acquired target entity so as to enjoy its listed status and associated goodwill- this transactional approach which is referred to as the Reverse Acquisition in mergers and acquisition parlance. Examples of this nature help to demonstrate how a deep understanding of the corporate assets such as IP and the like could influence decision making around business combinations. Indeed, many organizations often fail to appreciate the commercial value of, and the dangers to their Intellectual Property (IP), even when IP accounts for a high measure of the company’s worth when these corporate restructuring options are being executed.

 

When organizations develop their IP, there is usually this urge to make high returns from their investment despite their minimal resources. And when its objective is not maximized, it could be devastating for the company.[1]

 

A company’s assets may be broadly divided into two categories: Tangible assets – including structures, facilities, financial assets and infrastructure – and Intangible assets – ranging from human assets and knowledge, ideas, brands, goodwill, strategies and other intangible assets. Usually, corporeal assets have constituted a large chunk of company assets and they are considerable in determining the position of the company in the market place. Increasingly, and largely as a consequence of the information technology revolution and the growth of the service economy, companies are realizing that, the goodwill of a company is far more valuable than their physical assets.

 

In Nigeria, the essence of IP in business is insufficiently understood; it is probably under-valued, under-managed or under-exploited.[2] Worldwide, IP is recognized as a very relevant asset of many of the world’s largest and most influential companies; it is extremely key to market dominance and continuing profitability of leading corporations. It is often a major objective in mergers and acquisitions and knowledgeable companies are increasingly adopting permissible ways to relocate assets to areas where the tax obligation is low. Accounting Standards are not necessarily useful in demonstrating the worth of IP rights and intangible assets (IPRs) in company accounts[3]; however, an international accounting method could be adopted in the valuation of IP where the value of a company’s IP portfolio could be measured separately and independently of its tangible assets. It is worth mentioning that the dynamic of assets appreciation is changing and a paradigm shift to powerful software and ground-breaking thoughts as the main platform for generating income in most corporations worldwide is becoming commonplace. One crucial way of doing so is by protecting intangible assets within a suitable legal framework and where they meet the standards for intellectual property protection, acquiring and maintaining IP rights.[4]

In developed countries around the world, there is an ever-growing shift towards the knowledge economy, or industries based on innovation and intangible assets. In such a climate, businesses that base their operations on intangible assets and innovation have a higher likelihood of thriving. Intellectual property can help businesses legally protect and capitalize on these inventions. Contrary to popular belief, the number one reason firms acquire intellectual property is not for litigation purposes, but to have legal and transferable proof of ownership to some of their most important intangible assets. Intellectual property valuation can help corporations determine the true value of their businesses and capitalize on assets that they may not have been aware of possessing.[5]

Furthermore, changes in international commercial communities have influenced the expansion of business models where IP is a central element creating value and potential growth. In addition to these changes, international accounting practices place pressure on firms to recognize and value all identifiable intangible assets of a firm as part of a transaction, especially, in mergers and acquisitions.

As a result of these developments, proper valuation of IP, followed by measures to protect that value, have become a key element of the success and dynamism of a modern firm. The importance of intangible capital and its acquisition have accounted for more than half of the increased output in developed economies over the course of the last few decades.[6]

 

Diligence in IP Valuation
Significant due diligence should be undertaken when the fundamentals of a given transaction consist of assets such as trademarks, knowledge and technologies. The commercial standards of such transactions largely orbit around intellectual property and these could include trademarks, patents, industrial designs and copyrights.

Registered and granted intellectual property rights, such as granted patents, trademark registrations, and copyright registrations, which are acquired by application to intellectual property offices, provide legal evidence of a beneficiary’s ownership over intangible assets as well as give such beneficiary the right to exclude others from use of the rights. This means several things: owners have the means to protect themselves against infringement by competitors; owners can profitably license assets and sell same to others to provide them with rights they would otherwise not have; increase in the gross value of a beneficiary’s business.

The precise monetary worth of intellectual property, however, can be challenging to determine, as there are several factors that determine the value of the intangible assets in question. Registration or grant of an intellectual property right is sometimes a precondition to valuation, especially quantitative valuation, and enables the process of monetizing intangible assets.[7]

Conducting a valuation of intellectual property rights has significant benefits. Assessing the value of your patent, trademark or copyright may simplify the licensing or assignment process, and help you determine the royalty rates that should be paid to you as a result of using your intellectual property assets. Further, ascribing a reasonable valuation to your intellectual property, if not currently accounted for, increases the overall value of your business and provides you with collateral for loans or mortgages.[8]

The valuation of IP is therefore vital in the structure of commercial transactions. Unfortunately, this characteristic is often ignored by companies not knowledgeable in these sorts of deals, resulting in transactions that are either overestimated or underestimated or loss-making. It is therefore important to scrutinize and assess the worth of the IP during the negotiation process, before the conclusion of a commercial transaction. One of the key factors affecting a company’s success or failure is the degree of value attributed to the exploitation of IP. Management in these organizations clearly need to gain an understanding of the value of their IP rights. This is so because this understanding facilitates a deeper knowledge of the value to be placed on the assets under their management. Markets, institutions and shareholders need to be educated. Abuse can assume many forms ranging from outright sale of an asset, a joint venture or a licensing contract. It is equally important to mention that exploitation and abuse exposes a company to increased risks.[9]

 

IP Valuation Methods
The rule in commercial valuation of intellectual property relates to the fact that the value of an object cannot be estimated in the abstract and all that can be estimated is the value of such object in a particular place, particular time, and in a particular circumstance. More often than not, there could be two or more interested parties, and the valuations proposed could depend upon their circumstances. Failure to take these conditions and those of the owner into account could result in a less-than-satisfactory valuation.[10]

The value of intellectual property could be determined by many factors, but a major principle guiding valuation is how such intellectual property is valued when compared with similar assets in the same industry. When determining the worth of intellectual property, two methods of valuation have traditionally been used: Quantitative and Qualitative methods of valuation.

Quantitative valuation relies on measurable data or numerical information to produce an estimate of the value of your assets. It attempts to answer the question by providing a monetary value or contribution that the intellectual property provides, whether directly to the business or indirectly by increasing the value of other parts of the operation or appeal to investors.

Qualitative methods of valuation attempt to provide a non-monetary estimate of the value of intellectual property by rating it on the basis of its strategic impact, brand loyalty held by consumers, its impact on the company’s future growth, and other intangible metrics that do not rely solely on numbers[11].

There are majorly three major methods for IP valuation using the quantitative method: The Market Approach, the Cost Approach which is based on estimates of future economic benefits, and the Income Approach:

 

3.1 Quantitative Methods
3.1.1 Market Approach: The market approach is based on paid prices as a pointer for the value of an asset. The fundamental principle is that under certain conditions supply and demand lead to equilibrium in competitive markets. This approach encompasses the direct market value method and analogy method. The direct market value method seeks to use directly regarded transaction amounts for the subject asset. This method requires an energetic marketplace for the good, which means that the operated assets have to be same, willing purchasers and vendors can be found at any time and prices are widely known while the analogy method is when appraisers try to find transactions with comparable assets and transfer the paid prices to the valuation object. When comparable transactions are found, a common denominator or index has to be found in order to compute a multiplier for transferring the regarded prices to the valuation object[12].

 

3.1.2 Cost Approach

The cost approach seeks to ration the worth of a good by measuring the cost for the substitution of the asset by another. The basic supposition of this approach is that the cost to build or buy new possessions equals the value of its ownership. In this approach, it is basically composed of the reproduction cost and replacement cost methods. The reproduction cost method uses the cost of an exact imitation, while the replacement cost method guesstimates the cost of the manufacture or acquisition of a good with a corresponding benefit. This means the asset must have the same efficacy but may be quite different in method and appearance. Because of the uniqueness of intellectual property an exact imitation normally cannot be formed. So, when using a cost approach, it is more fitting to use replacement costs in this context[13]. Basically, what this means is the amount used in purchasing an IP asset should outweigh the cost of generating and using the same asset as both should be of equal value but not significantly much. This “cost to create” or “cost to replace” method disregards changes in the period value of money, upkeep and has very little to extol itself other than effortlessness of use.

 

3.1.3 Income Approach

Within the income approach diverse methods can be distinguished according to the way of determining the income flow: Direct Cash Flow Method, Relief from Royalty Method, Multi-period Excess Earnings Method, and Incremental Cash Flow Method.

The direct cash flow method uses the cash flows that are directly attributable to the subject asset. A condition for this is that the cash flows can be measured directly. This will especially be the case if the technology is not used in production processes by the owner himself but is made available to third parties by licensing. The license fees can be used directly as cash flows in the valuation calculation.

The idea of the relief from royalty method is that the income resulting from the ownership of the IP can be measured by the saved license fees, which would have to be paid, if the property would be licensed from another owner. The method requires that licensing agreements for similar assets can be monitored and transmitted.

The multi-period excess earnings method tries to isolate the cash flows attributable to the IP by deducting fictive fees (contributory asset charges) for all other assets from the entire cash flow of the unit. Those charges can be seen as rent or leasing fees for the use of those assets. So, the multi-period excess earnings method uses the opposite way of the relief from royalty method.

The incremental cash flow method seeks to value the benefit of IP by comparing the income of the considered unit with the property to a situation without it. The difference between the cash flows for each period in the two situations shows the additional cash flow that is attributable to the asset being valued[14].

The essence of the income approach is that it takes cognizance of the profits and economic value the remainder of the IP will generate after purchase.

There exist other less commonly used methods of quantitative valuation that often encompass elements of the larger umbrella methods described above but may focus on obtaining specific metrics. Such methods include the brand value equation method, liquidation value and income differential analysis. Depending on the purpose of prospective IP valuation, one or more of these methods may be helpful.

 

3.2 Qualitative Methods
3.2.1 Rating/scoring

To arrive at a definitive score in terms of valuation of IP, there are certain methods that one could adopt to achieve it. Most methods measure strategy, technological advancement and brand strength, as well as evaluating the risks and opportunities that are involved with the asset. The rating system can also be used for IP asset classification, as used in the Prism method, determining the type of function IP plays for the company and assigning a strategy based on the determination made.

3.2.2 Value indicators-based Method

It includes rating methods such as IP Quotient (IPQ), which primarily rates patents based on the strength of the portfolio and the variables that affect patents. This allows for internal comparisons to be drawn based on indicators.

3.2.3 Competitive advantage Method

It assesses the competitive advantage that is brought by intellectual property by comparing it to other non-branded companies in the market. It evaluates intellectual property on several characteristics (often a mix of qualitative and quantitative elements) to determine the brand’s performance and strength.

Because of their largely non-monetary nature, qualitative methods are often used for internal and/or strategic purposes. They can be used to understand the profitability of an IP portfolio and evaluate opportunities and risks, and to develop an overall strategy for businesses. Qualitative methods often tend to be based on common-sense indicators as well, making them viable for presentations to non-expert audiences and audiences without a strong financial grasp on the complicated quantitative measures that yield valuation metrics.[15]

 

3.3 IP Valuation in action

A useful illustration on the value of IP valuation may suffice here. Facebook’s billion-dollar acquisition of Instagram speaks volumes for the tremendous value attached to social media platforms. The fact that the social media giant would put forward such a large sum of money for a company (and a product) that generates no revenue (Instagram is free) is mesmerizing. This is even more so when one considers that Facebook acquired all of Instagram’s user base, instantly made inroads into the iOS and Android markets and has extended its own capabilities from merely being a social media network to a network that now facilitates the creation and sharing of unique user-generated content.

Before the purchase of Instagram, the projected value of the company was being rumored to range between $100 million to $500 million. Nevertheless, it was finally purchased at $1 billion. The rising valuation of the company was representative of the growing audience it had been garnering. It reached nearly 30 million registered users before it launched an Android app, a transformational event for the company. The summary is that Facebook purchased the entire essence of Instagram culminating into its IP valuation. The reason for the purchase is not the subject of this article, but the value attached to the brand known as Instagram is noteworthy here.[16] It is relevant to consider what approach Facebook adopted in this epoch-making merger. It would seem that it took the cost and income approach to arrive at its valuation. In adopting the cost approach, Facebook realized that the cost to acquire an IP asset in Instagram was far less significant in value than the cost of developing a new photo-sharing platform. In fact, the database and goodwill of Instagram will probably be more than that of creating a new platform.

Bringing this home to Nigeria, in 2018, another event which emphasized the importance of IP valuation was the horizontal merger between Yudala – the acquirer, and Konga – the target (both online retailing firms), after which both companies became one entity, operating under the Konga brand name. Before the merger, Konga was Nigeria’s second largest online mall, second only to Jumia. Yudala was also a strong online and offline retail business with an expansive network of fully stocked offline stores. Together, they have become Africa’s largest online e-commerce business. The two companies in the above example; Konga and Yudala, are businesses whose existence revolve around the utilization of their IP assets. The acquisition of Konga by Yudala was unique, in that, the acquirer changed its brand name to that of target because of the inherent IP value of the target.[17] Prior to the merger, it was perceived that Yudala’s agenda was essentially to utilize Konga’s trademark which, Yudala believed it could effectively leverage to boost her brick-and-mortar retail business model. What approach did Yudala latch on in achieving this merger? Considering that this was a novel merger in the e-commerce sector in Nigeria, the market approach to the acquisition of Konga may not have been significantly considered. The overwhelming approaches may have been the Income and Cost approach as Facebook did. In fact, there was an argument that buyers outside Lagos would be more comfortable visiting a Konga shop than a Yudala shop.

The pivotal analysis is that Yudala acquired Konga to leverage its trademark and technology in a bid to make Yudala go online, and to expand its offline stores. “In the end, trademark and technology were the targets in the acquisition.[18]

Furthermore, recent developments in the Nigerian banking sector have further underscored the value of branding and IP rights. In the recent ‘friendly merger’ of Access Bank (the acquirer) and Diamond Bank (the acquired) on April 1, 2019[19], the name ‘Access’ was retained while the re-branded logo of the acquired was retained. Indeed, Access Bank completely purchased the assets of Diamond Bank. However, the merger demonstrated how much value is attached to brands; Access Bank took into account that immense value and then opted to retain an essential IP asset of the acquired- the Diamond i.e. her bank logo. It is fair to deduce that Access bank attached strong weight to the value that the Diamond Bank brand would bring to the table in reaching the decision it did. Practically, Access Bank took the avenue of appreciating the market cost and the income cost of the IP in Diamond bank’s logo.

When assessing the value of an intellectual property, it is essential to first conduct due diligence to determine:

the existence, validity and enforceability of the IP rights;
the territorial scope covered by the IP rights;
the competitive scope of the IP rights by analyzing the scope of the granted claims;
the risk of invalidation of the granted IP rights;
whether the IP right is subject to a security interest in favor of a third party;
whether the IP rights have been assigned and/or licensed to others;
whether there is any issue with the ownership of the IP through an analysis of the chain of title;
whether the IP rights are being litigated; and whether the rights would rely on third parties’ intellectual property rights in order to mature to commercially viable products.[20]

Conclusion
We have examined critically, the different methods of undertaking IP assets valuation and the essence of their valuation. We have learnt that brand owners need to be more commercially aware of what their brand valuation could be worth. We also understand that the primary rule of commercial valuation is to the effect that the worth of assets cannot be quantified in the abstract and all that can be quantified is the value of an asset in a particular place, at a particular time, and in particular circumstances. It is strongly advised that entities that have the intention of valuing their IP should endeavor to use any of the quantitative approaches to achieve such valuation, and while embarking on this, professionals should be employed to do so observing the highest ethical standards and international best practice.

It is also recommended that brand owners should understand the importance of taking steps to protect their brands according to the laws of the land. This is important because, where brands are not adequately protected their owners may not be able to fully exploit the commercial value of the brand regardless of the method of valuation deployed.

 

This article was authored by Blessing Ajunwo-Choko and Doyin Fadare, both of whom practice at Alliance Law Firm.

 

 

REFERENCES:

[1]https://www.wipo.int/export/sites/www/meetings/en/2005/smes_qtc/presentations/wipo_smes_qtc_05_
king.pdf Accessed March 27, 2019

[2]https://www.wipo.int/export/sites/www/meetings/en/2005/smes_qtc/presentations/wipo_smes_qtc_05_
king.pdf Accessed March 27, 2019

[3]Ibid

[4]https://www.wipo.int/sme/en/ip_business/ip_asset/business_assets.htm accessed on March 27, 2019

[5]https://www.heerlaw.com/determining-value-intellectual-property accessed on January 28, 2020

[6] https://www.marsh.com/us/insights/research/importance-of-intellectual-property.html accessed on March 27, 2019

[7] https://www.heerlaw.com/monetizing-intellectual-property accessed on February 4, 2020

[8] ibid

[9] Ibid (1)

[10] Ibid

[11] Ibid (5)

[12]Valuation of Intellectual Property: A Review of Approaches and Methodshttps://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/a9e2/a7a4377ae882031424f3e81c6c2b5a92c257.pdf accessed on April 1, 2019

[13] Ibid

[14] Ibid

[15] Ibid (5)

[16] https://gigaom.com/2012/04/09/here-is-why-did-facebook-bought-instagram/ accessed on March 27, 2019

[17]http://www.jacksonettiandedu.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/10/ip-valuation-as-a-value-enhancement-1.pdf accessed on March 27, 2019

[18] Peter Oluka, Examining Konga-Yudala Merger https://techeconomy.ng/2018/04/23/examining-konga-yudala-merger/ accessed on March 27, 2019

[19] https://www.pmnewsnigeria.com/2019/04/01/merger-with-diamond-bank-access-launches-new-brand-logo/ accessed April 1, 2019

[20] https://www.tamimi.com/law-update-articles/intellectual-property-valuation-a-must-in-commercial-transactions/ accessed on March 27, 2019

 

262 Comments

  1. mexico drug stores pharmacies
    http://cmqpharma.com/# mexico drug stores pharmacies
    mexican mail order pharmacies

  2. medication from mexico pharmacy: mexican online pharmacy – medicine in mexico pharmacies

  3. Very interesting info!Perfect just what I was looking for!Raise range

  4. https://canadapharmast.online/# canadian pharmacy online

  5. canadian pharmacy drugs online: trustworthy canadian pharmacy – canadapharmacyonline
    http://indiapharmast.com/# best india pharmacy
    purple pharmacy mexico price list pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa п»їbest mexican online pharmacies

  6. п»їbest mexican online pharmacies: mexican drugstore online – medication from mexico pharmacy

  7. pharmacies in canada that ship to the us: canadian pharmacy world – canadian drug prices

  8. buying prescription drugs in mexico online mexican pharmaceuticals online mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs

  9. canadian neighbor pharmacy: my canadian pharmacy reviews – canadian pharmacy tampa
    https://canadapharmast.com/# legitimate canadian pharmacy online
    india pharmacy pharmacy website india top 10 pharmacies in india

  10. https://foruspharma.com/# buying prescription drugs in mexico online

  11. buying prescription drugs in mexico: mexico drug stores pharmacies – mexican pharmacy

  12. mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa mexican drugstore online mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa

  13. best online pharmacy india: Online medicine home delivery – buy medicines online in india

  14. buying from online mexican pharmacy: best online pharmacies in mexico – mexican pharmaceuticals online

  15. http://foruspharma.com/# reputable mexican pharmacies online

  16. buying prescription drugs in mexico mexico drug stores pharmacies mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs

  17. top 10 pharmacies in india: indianpharmacy com – Online medicine order

  18. indian pharmacy: best online pharmacy india – indian pharmacy
    http://canadapharmast.com/# canadapharmacyonline legit
    reputable mexican pharmacies online pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa reputable mexican pharmacies online

  19. indian pharmacy online: top online pharmacy india – reputable indian pharmacies

  20. indian pharmacy paypal: Online medicine order – п»їlegitimate online pharmacies india

  21. purple pharmacy mexico price list: mexico drug stores pharmacies – pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa
    http://canadapharmast.com/# canadian pharmacy online ship to usa
    canadian pharmacy online reviews my canadian pharmacy reviews legit canadian pharmacy

  22. mexico drug stores pharmacies: buying from online mexican pharmacy – mexico pharmacy

  23. http://indiapharmast.com/# online shopping pharmacy india

  24. buy doxycycline 100mg cheap: doxycycline 400 mg price – doxycycline medication pills

  25. https://doxycyclinedelivery.pro/# doxycyline
    amoxicillin 500 mg online generic for amoxicillin amoxicillin 500mg capsules

  26. paxlovid buy: Paxlovid over the counter – paxlovid india
    http://amoxildelivery.pro/# amoxicillin 500mg capsule buy online

  27. https://ciprodelivery.pro/# ciprofloxacin generic price

  28. paxlovid buy: Paxlovid buy online – paxlovid pharmacy
    http://ciprodelivery.pro/# buy cipro online without prescription
    п»їcipro generic buy cipro online canada buy generic ciprofloxacin

  29. http://doxycyclinedelivery.pro/# doxycycline 200 mg
    buy ciprofloxacin buy cipro cheap cipro

  30. http://amoxildelivery.pro/# amoxicillin 500mg prescription

  31. doxycycline capsules price in india: doxycycline order uk – buy doxycycline 100mg online
    http://clomiddelivery.pro/# how can i get clomid without a prescription

  32. buy cipro online without prescription: cipro 500mg best prices – cipro for sale

  33. amoxicillin 500 mg for sale: where can i buy amoxicillin over the counter – how much is amoxicillin
    https://clomiddelivery.pro/# clomid generic
    can you buy cheap clomid no prescription buying clomid pills where buy clomid price

  34. https://doxycyclinedelivery.pro/# doxycycline with out a rx

  35. https://amoxildelivery.pro/# where to get amoxicillin over the counter
    can i order generic clomid no prescription order cheap clomid no prescription get generic clomid tablets

  36. ciprofloxacin 500 mg tablet price: cipro for sale – ciprofloxacin
    http://clomiddelivery.pro/# where to buy generic clomid pills

  37. п»їcipro generic: ciprofloxacin 500mg buy online – buy cipro online without prescription

  38. doxycycline 100mg capsules buy: doxycycline tablets australia – tetracycline doxycycline
    http://doxycyclinedelivery.pro/# cost doxycycline australia
    doxycycline cap 50mg how to get doxycycline prescription doxycycline online india

  39. https://amoxildelivery.pro/# buy amoxicillin from canada
    doxycycline india cost doxycycline 60 mg doxycycline 400 mg tablet

  40. paxlovid price: paxlovid pill – paxlovid india
    http://doxycyclinedelivery.pro/# doxycycline 50mg capsules

  41. https://clomiddelivery.pro/# can you buy clomid without insurance

  42. can i order clomid: how to get cheap clomid without a prescription – how to get cheap clomid without a prescription
    http://doxycyclinedelivery.pro/# doxycycline 200 mg
    where to get cheap clomid prices can i buy generic clomid no prescription order generic clomid no prescription

  43. purchase cipro: buy cipro cheap – ciprofloxacin

  44. http://ciprodelivery.pro/# ciprofloxacin mail online
    where to buy generic clomid pill get generic clomid without rx where to buy generic clomid tablets

  45. can you buy clomid now: can i order generic clomid – cost clomid no prescription
    https://ciprodelivery.pro/# buy ciprofloxacin over the counter

  46. https://doxycyclinedelivery.pro/# buy doxycycline online nz

  47. cipro for sale: cipro – antibiotics cipro
    https://ciprodelivery.pro/# buy cipro online without prescription
    buy cipro online ciprofloxacin generic price ciprofloxacin generic

  48. https://paxloviddelivery.pro/# paxlovid price
    can i purchase clomid without prescription buy clomid no prescription buying clomid pills

  49. https://clomiddelivery.pro/# can you buy clomid no prescription

  50. buy cipro: purchase cipro – cipro for sale
    http://clomiddelivery.pro/# how to buy clomid no prescription

  51. paxlovid cost without insurance: paxlovid price – paxlovid covid

  52. https://amoxildelivery.pro/# amoxicillin 500 coupon
    buy cipro online without prescription ciprofloxacin 500mg buy online buy ciprofloxacin

  53. buying cheap clomid no prescription: how to get cheap clomid pills – can i order generic clomid
    http://doxycyclinedelivery.pro/# purchase doxycycline online

  54. cost clomid price: how to get generic clomid tablets – cost clomid no prescription

  55. http://doxycyclinedelivery.pro/# buy doxycycline 100mg tablets

  56. http://doxycyclinedelivery.pro/# doxycycline 100mg without a prescription
    paxlovid price Paxlovid buy online paxlovid covid

  57. doxycycline online singapore: doxycycline india – doxycycline 100 mg forsale outside the us
    https://ciprodelivery.pro/# buy cipro online canada

  58. buy cipro without rx: ciprofloxacin generic price – cipro

  59. Paxlovid buy online: paxlovid generic – п»їpaxlovid

  60. buy amoxicillin 500mg usa: canadian pharmacy amoxicillin – amoxicillin online pharmacy

  61. amoxicillin capsules 250mg: where can i buy amoxicillin without prec – amoxicillin without prescription

  62. best online pharmacies in mexico: reputable mexican pharmacies online – п»їbest mexican online pharmacies

  63. pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa: medicine in mexico pharmacies – buying from online mexican pharmacy

  64. reputable mexican pharmacies online mexican pharmaceuticals online mexican pharmaceuticals online

  65. mexican rx online: pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa – mexico drug stores pharmacies

  66. mexico drug stores pharmacies: reputable mexican pharmacies online – mexican mail order pharmacies

  67. mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa mexican rx online mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa

  68. п»їbest mexican online pharmacies: medication from mexico pharmacy – medication from mexico pharmacy

  69. http://mexicandeliverypharma.com/# mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs

  70. mexico drug stores pharmacies: buying prescription drugs in mexico – reputable mexican pharmacies online

  71. mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs: mexico pharmacies prescription drugs – best online pharmacies in mexico

  72. mexico pharmacy best online pharmacies in mexico buying from online mexican pharmacy

  73. mexican rx online: mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa – buying from online mexican pharmacy

  74. reputable mexican pharmacies online: purple pharmacy mexico price list – best online pharmacies in mexico

  75. mexican mail order pharmacies: mexican rx online – purple pharmacy mexico price list

  76. mexican rx online: medicine in mexico pharmacies – buying from online mexican pharmacy

  77. reputable mexican pharmacies online: mexican mail order pharmacies – mexican drugstore online

  78. mexican rx online best online pharmacies in mexico mexico drug stores pharmacies

  79. mexican mail order pharmacies: medication from mexico pharmacy – reputable mexican pharmacies online

  80. medicine in mexico pharmacies: mexican pharmaceuticals online – purple pharmacy mexico price list

  81. purple pharmacy mexico price list: mexico drug stores pharmacies – pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa

  82. mexican pharmacy buying prescription drugs in mexico mexican drugstore online

  83. mexican pharmaceuticals online: mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs – mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa

  84. mexican rx online: п»їbest mexican online pharmacies – mexican mail order pharmacies

  85. mexico drug stores pharmacies: mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa – mexican mail order pharmacies

  86. mexico pharmacy mexico pharmacies prescription drugs purple pharmacy mexico price list

  87. mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs: mexico drug stores pharmacies – mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs

  88. mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa: medicine in mexico pharmacies – mexican drugstore online

  89. mexico drug stores pharmacies: mexico pharmacies prescription drugs – pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa

  90. purple pharmacy mexico price list mexico pharmacies prescription drugs mexico drug stores pharmacies

  91. pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa: mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs – mexican mail order pharmacies

  92. buying from online mexican pharmacy: pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa – mexico drug stores pharmacies

  93. reputable mexican pharmacies online: mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa – mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa

  94. pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa: buying prescription drugs in mexico online – mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs

  95. medication from mexico pharmacy: mexican mail order pharmacies – mexico pharmacies prescription drugs

  96. mexican pharmaceuticals online: buying prescription drugs in mexico – mexico drug stores pharmacies

  97. mexican drugstore online: best online pharmacies in mexico – mexican pharmaceuticals online

  98. п»їbest mexican online pharmacies: mexican drugstore online – buying from online mexican pharmacy

  99. best online pharmacies in mexico mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs best online pharmacies in mexico

  100. п»їbest mexican online pharmacies: purple pharmacy mexico price list – mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa

  101. mexican drugstore online: reputable mexican pharmacies online – best online pharmacies in mexico

  102. п»їbest mexican online pharmacies: medicine in mexico pharmacies – purple pharmacy mexico price list

  103. mexico drug stores pharmacies: purple pharmacy mexico price list – mexico drug stores pharmacies

  104. mexico drug stores pharmacies: medication from mexico pharmacy – mexican rx online

  105. mexican pharmaceuticals online: mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa – buying from online mexican pharmacy

  106. buying prescription drugs in mexico online п»їbest mexican online pharmacies mexican mail order pharmacies

  107. mexican mail order pharmacies: buying prescription drugs in mexico online – mexico drug stores pharmacies

  108. mexican rx online: mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs – purple pharmacy mexico price list

  109. medicine in mexico pharmacies: buying from online mexican pharmacy – buying prescription drugs in mexico

  110. п»їbest mexican online pharmacies medication from mexico pharmacy buying from online mexican pharmacy

  111. pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa: mexican drugstore online – mexico drug stores pharmacies

  112. mexican pharmaceuticals online: mexico drug stores pharmacies – best online pharmacies in mexico

  113. buying prescription drugs in mexico: pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa – mexican rx online

  114. mexican drugstore online: buying prescription drugs in mexico online – mexican drugstore online

  115. purple pharmacy mexico price list: medicine in mexico pharmacies – mexican drugstore online

  116. buying from online mexican pharmacy buying prescription drugs in mexico online mexico drug stores pharmacies

  117. mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa: purple pharmacy mexico price list – buying from online mexican pharmacy

  118. medicine in mexico pharmacies: medication from mexico pharmacy – buying from online mexican pharmacy

  119. cytotec pills buy online: cytotec pills buy online – cytotec online

  120. buy cytotec online п»їcytotec pills online buy cytotec pills

  121. http://zithromaxbestprice.pro/# where can you buy zithromax

  122. zithromax capsules 250mg zithromax online australia zithromax drug

  123. buy cytotec pills online cheap: order cytotec online – order cytotec online

  124. https://cytotecbestprice.pro/# cytotec pills buy online

  125. http://cytotecbestprice.pro/# Misoprostol 200 mg buy online

  126. tamoxifen 20 mg tablet tamoxifen postmenopausal tamoxifen bone pain

  127. propecia rx: cost cheap propecia for sale – buy propecia for sale

  128. https://propeciabestprice.pro/# buy propecia without rx

  129. http://cytotecbestprice.pro/# Cytotec 200mcg price

  130. tamoxifen mechanism of action tamoxifen headache nolvadex price

  131. generic propecia for sale: cost of propecia without insurance – order propecia without rx

  132. buy cytotec online fast delivery: buy cytotec in usa – buy cytotec

  133. cytotec online: Abortion pills online – buy cytotec pills

  134. prednisone price canada: prednisone rx coupon – india buy prednisone online

  135. zithromax 1000 mg pills: zithromax generic cost – zithromax prescription online

  136. https://propeciabestprice.pro/# cost of generic propecia without insurance

  137. prednisone drug costs: prednisone purchase online – where to buy prednisone uk

  138. comprare farmaci online con ricetta: Avanafil 50 mg – farmacia online piГ№ conveniente
    http://avanafil.pro/# п»їFarmacia online migliore
    cerco viagra a buon prezzo esiste il viagra generico in farmacia miglior sito per comprare viagra online

  139. Farmacia online miglior prezzo: Cialis generico prezzo – Farmacia online piГ№ conveniente

  140. farmacia online piГ№ conveniente: Farmacie che vendono Cialis senza ricetta – farmacie online sicure
    https://viagragenerico.site/# viagra originale in 24 ore contrassegno
    farmaci senza ricetta elenco super kamagra farmacia online

  141. farmacia online: Avanafil a cosa serve – farmacie online autorizzate elenco

  142. Farmacia online piГ№ conveniente: kamagra oral jelly consegna 24 ore – Farmacia online piГ№ conveniente

  143. Farmacie on line spedizione gratuita: Avanafil compresse – Farmacie online sicure

  144. farmacia online: Cialis generico farmacia – farmacia online senza ricetta

  145. viagra 50 mg prezzo in farmacia: viagra generico – viagra originale in 24 ore contrassegno
    https://cialisgenerico.life/# farmaci senza ricetta elenco
    miglior sito dove acquistare viagra viagra prezzo esiste il viagra generico in farmacia

  146. farmacie online sicure: super kamagra – comprare farmaci online con ricetta

  147. comprare farmaci online con ricetta: Cialis generico prezzo – farmacie online affidabili

  148. http://viagragenerico.site/# cialis farmacia senza ricetta

  149. farmacie online autorizzate elenco: kamagra – farmacie online affidabili
    http://avanafil.pro/# comprare farmaci online con ricetta
    п»їFarmacia online migliore Farmacie online sicure farmacie online autorizzate elenco

  150. п»їFarmacia online migliore: Farmacia online piu conveniente – farmacie online affidabili

  151. farmacia online: avanafil 100 mg prezzo – farmacie online autorizzate elenco

  152. farmaci senza ricetta elenco: Farmacie che vendono Cialis senza ricetta – farmacie online sicure

  153. http://avanafil.pro/# Farmacia online piГ№ conveniente

  154. Farmacia online miglior prezzo: kamagra oral jelly – Farmacia online miglior prezzo
    https://cialisgenerico.life/# comprare farmaci online con ricetta
    comprare farmaci online all’estero avanafil in farmacia top farmacia online

  155. viagra 100 mg prezzo in farmacia: viagra farmacia – miglior sito dove acquistare viagra

  156. top farmacia online: Farmacia online piu conveniente – farmacie online affidabili

  157. blue pill viagra: Cheap Viagra 100mg – viagra coupon
    http://tadalafil.auction/# generic cialis quick shipping

  158. over the counter alternative to viagra: Viagra online price – viagra

  159. cialis canadian: Generic Tadalafil 20mg price – cialisnonprecription
    https://sildenafil.llc/# viagra cost
    cialis overnight Generic Cialis without a doctor prescription cialis dopoxetine

  160. https://tadalafil.auction/# cialis soft tabs canada
    how to buy cialis online from canada cialis without a doctor prescription best place to get cialis without pesricption

  161. viagra without doctor prescription: Viagra online price – 100 mg viagra lowest price

  162. cialis store in philippines: Buy Tadalafil 20mg – low cost cialis
    https://tadalafil.auction/# buy cialis at walmart

  163. https://tadalafil.auction/# generic cialis canada

  164. cialis 5mg tablets: Buy Tadalafil 20mg – cialis online pharmacy australian
    https://sildenafil.llc/# over the counter alternative to viagra
    viagra samples Cheap generic Viagra viagra generic

  165. generic viagra overnight: Cheap Viagra online – ed pills that work better than viagra

  166. generic viagra 100mg: Buy Viagra online in USA – order viagra online
    https://tadalafil.auction/# cialis online in canada

  167. buying viagra or cialis min canada: Buy Tadalafil 20mg – cialis black 800 to buy in the uk one pill
    https://tadalafil.auction/# buy cialis and receive in 48 hrs
    viagra coupon Buy Viagra online cheap viagra price

  168. http://tadalafil.auction/# pay cialis with pay pal

  169. free viagra: Buy Viagra online in USA – buy viagra

  170. http://sildenafil.llc/# generic viagra available
    how long does viagra last Buy Viagra online cheap п»їover the counter viagra

  171. buy cialis online overnight delivery cialis side effects women or cheapest cialis tadalafil 20 mg
    http://ewin.biz/jsonp/?url=https://tadalafil.auction:: buy cialis online in australia
    pay pal for cialis walmart price for cialis and where to buy cialis in canada 36 hour cialis no prescription

  172. viagra vs cialis: Buy Viagra online cheap – blue pill viagra
    https://sildenafil.llc/# viagra pills
    100mg viagra without a doctor prescription Cheap Viagra 100mg canadian viagra

  173. medication from mexico pharmacy: mexican pharmacy – best online pharmacies in mexico
    http://edpillpharmacy.store/# cheap ed treatment

  174. cheapest online pharmacy india: Indian pharmacy international shipping – online pharmacy india

  175. https://edpillpharmacy.store/# erectile dysfunction meds online
    get ed meds online

  176. mexican pharmacy: medication from mexico pharmacy – mexican pharmacy
    http://edpillpharmacy.store/# cheap ed medication
    indian pharmacy paypal Top mail order pharmacies top 10 online pharmacy in india

  177. online ed treatments: Best ED meds online – where to buy erectile dysfunction pills

  178. http://mexicopharmacy.win/# buying from online mexican pharmacy

  179. https://edpillpharmacy.store/# cheap ed meds
    ed prescription online

  180. cheap ed treatment: cheap ed pills online – ed online pharmacy
    https://mexicopharmacy.win/# mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa

  181. indianpharmacy com: Online India pharmacy – indianpharmacy com

  182. http://indiapharmacy.shop/# Online medicine home delivery
    online ed treatments

  183. http://edpillpharmacy.store/# low cost ed meds online

  184. mexico pharmacy: Certified Mexican pharmacy – reputable mexican pharmacies online
    http://edpillpharmacy.store/# online erectile dysfunction medication
    top rated ed pills Cheapest online ED treatment ed pills cheap

  185. where to buy ed pills: Cheapest online ED treatment – erection pills online
    https://indiapharmacy.shop/# reputable indian online pharmacy

  186. pills for ed online: Best ED pills non prescription – order ed pills online

  187. mexico pharmacies prescription drugs: Medicines Mexico – purple pharmacy mexico price list

  188. http://indiapharmacy.shop/# reputable indian pharmacies

  189. online erectile dysfunction: Best ED meds online – buy erectile dysfunction medication
    http://mexicopharmacy.win/# mexico drug stores pharmacies

  190. indian pharmacy paypal top 10 pharmacies in india or cheapest online pharmacy india
    http://www.publicanalyst.com/?URL=indiapharmacy.shop indian pharmacy
    indianpharmacy com online shopping pharmacy india and reputable indian online pharmacy top 10 pharmacies in india

  191. purple pharmacy mexico price list: Best pharmacy in Mexico – buying prescription drugs in mexico online

  192. buy ed meds: ED meds online with insurance – cheapest erectile dysfunction pills
    https://edpillpharmacy.store/# online ed prescription
    buy medicines online in india Cheapest online pharmacy world pharmacy india

  193. cheap ed meds: Best ED pills non prescription – ed treatments online
    https://indiapharmacy.shop/# online shopping pharmacy india

  194. mexico pharmacies prescription drugs: п»їbest mexican online pharmacies – reputable mexican pharmacies online

  195. http://mexicopharmacy.win/# pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa

  196. mail order pharmacy india: Top online pharmacy in India – indian pharmacy paypal
    http://indiapharmacy.shop/# india pharmacy mail order

  197. pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa: Medicines Mexico – buying prescription drugs in mexico online

  198. http://indiapharmacy.shop/# buy medicines online in india

  199. order ed meds online: cheap ed pills online – cheapest ed treatment

  200. indian pharmacy online: indian pharmacy – indian pharmacy paypal

  201. https://indiapharmacy.shop/# pharmacy website india

  202. Online medicine order: Online pharmacy – indian pharmacy online
    https://edpillpharmacy.store/# best online ed pills
    buying prescription drugs in mexico mexican pharmacy mexico drug stores pharmacies

  203. buying prescription drugs in mexico online: Purple pharmacy online ordering – purple pharmacy mexico price list

  204. https://indiapharmacy.shop/# mail order pharmacy india

  205. indian pharmacy paypal: Online pharmacy – top 10 online pharmacy in india

  206. buy prescription drugs from india: Cheapest online pharmacy – cheapest online pharmacy india
    http://mexicopharmacy.win/# mexican rx online
    mexican mail order pharmacies Mexico pharmacy online buying prescription drugs in mexico online

  207. where to buy ed pills: Best ED meds online – ed prescriptions online

  208. http://indiapharmacy.shop/# mail order pharmacy india

  209. http://edpillpharmacy.store/# where to buy ed pills

  210. erectile dysfunction medicine online: online ed prescription same-day – buy ed medication online
    https://indiapharmacy.shop/# buy prescription drugs from india
    erectile dysfunction medications online Best ED meds online ed meds cheap

  211. ed prescriptions online: ED meds online with insurance – online ed medicine

  212. pharmacy website india: Online pharmacy – mail order pharmacy india

  213. buy erectile dysfunction treatment: cheap ed pills online – get ed meds today

  214. mexico pharmacies prescription drugs: mexican pharmacy – buying prescription drugs in mexico online
    https://indiapharmacy.shop/# п»їlegitimate online pharmacies india
    order ed meds online online ed prescription same-day cheapest online ed meds

  215. ed prescriptions online: online ed prescription same-day – how to get ed pills

  216. Online medicine home delivery: Online India pharmacy – п»їlegitimate online pharmacies india

  217. best india pharmacy: Top mail order pharmacies – top 10 online pharmacy in india
    https://mexicopharmacy.win/# mexico drug stores pharmacies
    where to get ed pills Best ED pills non prescription how to get ed pills

  218. buy cytotec in usa https://tamoxifen.bid/# does tamoxifen cause joint pain
    lasix 100 mg

  219. lasix furosemide: cheap lasix – lasix furosemide 40 mg

  220. buy cytotec over the counter: cytotec best price – Abortion pills online
    http://lipitor.guru/# buy cheap lipitor online
    lipitor coupon Lipitor 10 mg price lipitor 20mg

  221. tamoxifen rash: tamoxifen breast cancer – tamoxifen hormone therapy

  222. http://lisinopril.guru/# lisinopril 10mg tabs

  223. buy misoprostol over the counter https://lisinopril.guru/# how much is lisinopril 5 mg
    lasix medication

  224. lisinopril: cheap lisinopril – lisinopril online

  225. furosemide 100mg lasix online lasix generic name

  226. Abortion pills online http://furosemide.win/# lasix furosemide
    lasix medication

  227. https://lipitor.guru/# canada prescription price lipitor

  228. alternative to tamoxifen: buy tamoxifen citrate – how to prevent hair loss while on tamoxifen
    http://lisinopril.guru/# zestril 20 mg price in india
    cheap lipitor 20 mg cheapest ace inhibitor lipitor 40 mg

  229. lipitor generic brand: lipitor 100mg – buy lipitor from canada

  230. Abortion pills online https://lisinopril.guru/# lisinopril 60 mg daily
    generic lasix

  231. http://lisinopril.guru/# lisinopril tabs 4mg

  232. lipitor coupon: cheapest ace inhibitor – lipitor coupon

  233. lasix furosemide: cheap lasix – furosemide 100mg
    http://furosemide.win/# lasix pills
    order cytotec online buy cytotec online Cytotec 200mcg price

  234. buy lipitor cheap buy atorvastatin online pfizer lipitor

  235. cytotec pills buy online https://tamoxifen.bid/# effexor and tamoxifen
    furosemide 100 mg

  236. tamoxifen side effects forum: buy tamoxifen citrate – nolvadex gynecomastia

  237. buy cytotec pills online cheap: buy cytotec online – cytotec pills buy online

  238. buy cytotec online: buy cytotec online – buy cytotec
    https://lisinopril.guru/# zestoretic
    100 mg lisinopril Lisinopril online prescription buy lisinopril online canada

  239. cytotec buy online usa https://lisinopril.guru/# zestril 10 mg price in india
    lasix generic name

  240. lipitor 20 mg generic: Atorvastatin 20 mg buy online – generic lipitor canada pharmacy

  241. how much is lipitor discount lipitor online pharmacy or cost of lipitor in mexico
    http://forum.my-yo.ru/away.php?s=http://lipitor.guru best price for generic lipitor
    cheap lipitor generic lipitor canada pharmacy and lipitor 10mg price in india lipitor generic atorvastatin

  242. tamoxifen bone density: Purchase Nolvadex Online – tamoxifen buy

  243. Cytotec 200mcg price http://lisinopril.guru/# buy lisinopril
    lasix medication

  244. lasix 40 mg: cheap lasix – lasix generic
    https://lisinopril.guru/# buy lisinopril 20 mg without prescription
    lexapro and tamoxifen buy tamoxifen online tamoxifen rash pictures

  245. lasix 100mg: lasix uses – generic lasix

  246. lisinopril 40 mg for sale how much is lisinopril 5 mg or prinivil drug cost
    https://maps.google.mv/url?q=https://lisinopril.guru zestril 5 mg tablets
    lisinopril in mexico lisinopril 5 mg price and cost of brand name lisinopril where can i order lisinopril online

  247. lisinopril 40 mg on line: Lisinopril refill online – generic lisinopril 5 mg

  248. Misoprostol 200 mg buy online https://cytotec.pro/# cytotec pills buy online
    lasix medication

  249. buy cheap lisinopril 40 mg no prescription: Lisinopril refill online – generic zestoretic
    http://lipitor.guru/# lipitor medicine price
    buy lisinopril 20 mg buy lisinopril how much is lisinopril

  250. generic zestril: Buy Lisinopril 20 mg online – generic lisinopril 10 mg

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *