The judiciary plays a crucial role in the administration of justice. Applicable tax laws in Nigeria clearly define the procedures for tax appeal and for challenging any decision of tax authorities. Unfortunately, taxpayers hardly explore this avenue in asserting their rights and entitlements in the wake of tax related disputes. This creates situations where tax payers yield to the demands or directives of tax authorities even when they have a good cause of action. On many occasions a settlement arrangement is reached and the tax payer settles the alleged liability in pre-agreed instalments, unconscious of the notion that, a course of action not explored may continuously culminate to injury without remedy. This notion is most evident in the area of tax disputes as tax is a periodic and recurrent obligation owed by tax payers to the government based on the provisions of relevant tax laws. As Benjamin Franklin once said: ” … in this world, nothing is certain except death and taxes“. Seeking judicial intervention on those theeting and recurrent tax issues may earn you unquantifiable tax savings and bring the much-needed succour to your business.
The recent legislative and fiscal policy reforms aimed at attracting investment and enabling ease of doing business in Nigerian may not yield the desired result without active judicial intervention. For instance, a critical look back into history reveals that the foundation for the framework of our criminal justice system, constitutional law, corporate governance, and electoral laws were laid down by the Nigerian judiciary, such that, certain legislative provisions cannot be cited without immediate reference to relevant judicial pronouncements on interpretation and application of such legislative provisions. This level of judicial activism is also needed in tax administration. However, this hinges significantly on the level of awareness of the tax payers. The process starts with the tax payer recognizing existing rights, entitlements and courses of action in any given circumstance that may warrant commencement of a tax appeal. Since it is practically impossible for the legislature to make laws applicable to all facts and circumstances, it behoves on taxpayers to initiate tax appeal processes in deserving cases so as to create the avenue for judicial intervention. This will develop the law and create the much-needed certainty in tax administration.
Tax Appeal Procedure
Based on the provisions of section 13(2) of the Fifth Schedule to the Federal Inland Revenue Service (FIRS) Establishment Act and other applicable tax laws, a taxpayer served with a notice of tax assessment or any decision of the tax authority may issue a notice of objection to such tax assessment or decision within a period of 30 days. The tax authority will either accept the objection and withdraw/revise the assessment or reject the objection. Where the tax authority rejects the objection, a notice of refusal to amend (NORA) will be issued and served on the taxpayer. Upon receiving a NORA, the taxpayer may within 30 days institute an appeal challenging the assessment or decision of the tax authority before the Tax Appeal Tribunal (TAT) or court of competent jurisdiction.
Presentation of Facts in Tax Disputes
In seeking redress through the tax appeal process, it is important to aptly present the peculiar facts, plight and circumstances of the taxpayer’s affairs or business operations. All relevant facts should be presented with verifiable supporting documents. This is an essential feature of our adversarial legal system. Following the maxim Ubi jus ibi remedium, the general disposition of the court or tribunal is to do justice in any given circumstance. Thus, the course of justice will, often times, be served whenever the facts and peculiar circumstances of a case are properly laid before a court or tribunal no matter how ambiguous the provisions of applicable laws may be. A review of judgements delivered in previous tax appeals will stress this further. For instance, the judgement delivered by the TAT in the case between Prime Plastichem Nigeria Limited (PPNL) and the FIRS is a pointer to the responsibility of tax payer to present clear and credible facts in substantiating any claim. In that case, PPNL, a private limited liability company engaged in the business of trading in imported plastics and petrochemicals, in its 2013 Transfer Pricing documentation, applied the Comparable Uncontrolled Price (CUP) method in evaluating the arm’s length nature of its purchase of petrochemical products from its foreign related party, Vinmar Overseas Limited (Vinmar). This was done by comparing the prices at which Vinmar sold similar products to third party customers. However, in 2014, Vinmar did not transact with third party customers in Nigeria, as such, there was no comparable information available to apply the CUP. Consequently, PPNL was constrained to apply the Transactional Net Margin Method (TNMM) in evaluating the purchase of petrochemical products from Vinmar.
In 2016, the FIRS reviewed PPNL’s Transfer Pricing documentation and disregarded the CUP method applied in the 2013 Transfer Pricing documentation. The FIRS applied TNMM to both 2013 and 2014 transactions, and issued an assessment of ₦1.74 billion. Both parties disagreed on the applicable profit level indicator (PLI) to be adopted in applying the TNMM and the comparable selected in the TNMM analysis. PPNL appealed to the TAT. However, in the course of the proceedings relevant facts and credible evidence justifying the use of CUP method in 2014 assessment year were not presented before the TAT rather, the powers of the FIRS, under applicable laws and regulations, to disregard CUP method used in 2014 assessment year was challenged. Other legal issues were also raised and argued vehemently. On 19 February 2020, the Tribunal upheld the FIRS’ assessment. According to the TAT, Since PPNL was unable to provide to the FIRS reliable information that satisfactorily explained its use of CUP method for 2014 assessment year, the FIRS has no choice but to jettison the CUP method used and adopt the TNMM for 2014 and 2015 assessment years respectively.
It is clear from the decision of the TAT that PPNL has not proved its case to the satisfaction of the TAT to enable it to be entitled to the claims and reliefs sought against the FIRS. What was also lacking was detailed explanation of the peculiar circumstances and processes of PPNL’s group operations.
Another glaring example is the judgment delivered in Oando v. FIRS during the “pre–Finance Act era”. The Finance Act 2019 expressly excluded franked investment income and retained earnings that has suffered tax from the purview of excess dividend tax. It is common knowledge that prior to enactment of the Finance Act 2019, implementation of Section 19 of the Companies Income Tax Act (i.e., excess dividend tax rule) created a lot of controversy and was a major pain point for holding companies in Nigeria. In the absence of express legislative provisions, the Court of Appeal in that case was inclined to do justice by excluding dividend declared from retained earnings that has suffered tax from excess dividend tax. This can be inferred from the analysis made and words used in the judgment. However, the Court of Appeal was unable to rule in favour of the tax payer in that case because sufficient facts substantiating the source of dividend payments were not presented before the court. According to the court, had there been clear evidence that the dividends in issue were sourced from retained earnings which had previously been taxed, the court would have held that such dividend payments should not be subjected to excess dividend tax rule even in the absence of express legislative provisions.
The handful of cases referred to above demonstrates the importance of identifying supporting documents and facts that will substantiate a tax payer’s position in the event of a tax dispute. Judgement or rulings made in the course of hearing a tax appeal forms part of precedents and reference points in subsequent appeals. This will develop the legal system and create certainty and clarity in many areas of the law. But, first, the tax payer must opt to institute a tax appeal and secondly, prosecute the appeal diligently by providing all material facts before the court or tribunal so that the substance of the appeal will not be eroded by legal technicalities or insufficiency of evidence.
Conclusion
To obtain the needed judicial intervention, the peculiar facts pertaining to the operations of the taxpayers must be aptly presented and substantiated with credible evidence. Identifying the facts that are in dispute, relevant documents required to substantiate grounds of objection, and understanding provisions of applicable laws are crucial to effective tax dispute resolution process.
Author
Joshua Akhator is the director and head of Tax, Transfer Pricing and Restructuring unit of Alliance Law Firm. He is a renowned legal and tax expert with about 14 years of experience in tax planning, mergers and acquisitions, advisory, and compliance transactions. Joshua is a member of the Nigerian Bar Association and the International Bar Association. He is also a chartered tax practitioner certified by the Chartered Institute of Taxation of Nigeria.
M +23407062682591
Tel:+234-1-9035352-5, 2707471-2
97 Comments
Полностью трендовые новинки индустрии.
Абсолютно все новости самых влиятельных подуимов.
Модные дома, лейблы, высокая мода.
Новое место для стильныех людей.
https://malemoda.ru/
Самые стильные новости индустрии.
Все эвенты всемирных подуимов.
Модные дома, лейблы, высокая мода.
Свежее место для трендовых людей.
https://fashionvipclub.ru/
Наиболее свежие новинки моды.
Важные эвенты всемирных подуимов.
Модные дома, лейблы, гедонизм.
Приятное место для трендовых хайпбистов.
https://sneakero.ru/
Самые важные новости мировых подиумов.
Все события самых влиятельных подуимов.
Модные дома, бренды, гедонизм.
Самое лучшее место для трендовых людей.
https://sneakerside.ru/
Наиболее актуальные новости индустрии.
Важные события лучших подуимов.
Модные дома, торговые марки, высокая мода.
Самое лучшее место для стильныех хайпбистов.
https://sneakersgo.ru/
Latest watch news and events. Actual collections, models. All information about cult watch companies.
https://chrono.luxepodium.com/
Полностью свежие новинки моды.
Абсолютно все эвенты самых влиятельных подуимов.
Модные дома, лейблы, haute couture.
Свежее место для трендовых людей.
https://ulmoda.ru/
Самые актуальные новости моды.
Важные мероприятия известнейших подуимов.
Модные дома, торговые марки, высокая мода.
Свежее место для модных хайпбистов.
https://luxury.superpodium.com/
Fashion, luxe, hedonism
Perfect fashion site for hypebeasts and stylish people.
Style news, events. New collections, collaborations, drops.
https://watch.lepodium.net/
Fashion, luxury, travel
The best style portal for hypebeasts and stylish people.
Style news, events. Fresh collections, collaborations, drops.
https://dubai.luxepodium.com/
Style, luxury, hedonism
Good fashion site for hypebeasts and cute people.
Industry news, events. Fresh collections, collaborations, drops.
https://watch.lepodium.net/
Style, luxe, hedonism
Good fashion site for hypebeasts and cute people.
Style news, events. Last collections, collaborations, drops.
https://london.luxepodium.com/
Style, luxury, lifestyle
Good style site for hypebeasts and stylish people.
Podium news, events. Latest collections, collaborations, limited editions.
https://lepodium.in/
Несомненно важные события моды.
Все новости лучших подуимов.
Модные дома, лейблы, гедонизм.
Новое место для модных людей.
https://richlifestyle.ru/
Абсолютно все трендовые новости часового мира – новые коллекции культовых часовых компаний.
Точно все коллекции часов от бюджетных до очень дорогих.
https://podium24.ru/
Очень актуальные события подиума.
Актуальные новости всемирных подуимов.
Модные дома, торговые марки, гедонизм.
Свежее место для модных людей.
https://furluxury.ru/
Абсолютно все свежие события часового мира – актуальные новинки лучших часовых компаний.
Абсолютно все варианты хронографов от доступных до супер гедонистических.
https://watchco.ru/
Избранные свежие новости часового искусства – новые новинки известных часовых марок.
Все варианты часов от недорогих до очень люксовых.
https://bitwatch.ru/
Очень стильные события мировых подиумов.
Все эвенты известнейших подуимов.
Модные дома, бренды, гедонизм.
Самое лучшее место для трендовых людей.
https://balenciager.ru/
Несомненно свежие новинки мировых подиумов.
Исчерпывающие события всемирных подуимов.
Модные дома, бренды, haute couture.
Самое лучшее место для модных людей.
https://outstreet.ru/
Избранные актуальные новости мира часов – трендовые модели легендарных часовых компаний.
Все варианты часов от дешевых до супер роскошных.
https://bitwatch.ru/
Полностью важные новинки индустрии.
Актуальные новости известнейших подуимов.
Модные дома, лейблы, высокая мода.
Приятное место для трендовых людей.
https://luxe-moda.ru/
LeCoupon: свежие события для любителей вещевого шоппинга
Новости, события, стильные образы, эвенты, коллекции, показы.
https://qrmoda.ru/
LeCoupon: свежие новости для любителей fashion шоппинга
Лента новостей, события, модные луки, мероприятия, дропы, подиум.
https://qrmoda.ru/
I needs to spend some time learning much more or understanding more.
Точно важные новинки мировых подиумов.
Актуальные мероприятия лучших подуимов.
Модные дома, бренды, гедонизм.
Самое лучшее место для модных хайпбистов.
https://fashion5.ru/
Наиболее стильные события модного мира.
Исчерпывающие события всемирных подуимов.
Модные дома, торговые марки, гедонизм.
Новое место для стильныех хайпбистов.
https://egomoda.ru/
Самые важные новости индустрии.
Исчерпывающие эвенты лучших подуимов.
Модные дома, торговые марки, гедонизм.
Интересное место для стильныех людей.
https://rfsneakers.ru
Очень актуальные события индустрии.
Важные события всемирных подуимов.
Модные дома, торговые марки, гедонизм.
Свежее место для стильныех хайпбистов.
https://whitesneaker.ru/
Самые актуальные новости мира fashion.
Актуальные эвенты лучших подуимов.
Модные дома, торговые марки, haute couture.
Самое лучшее место для модных хайпбистов.
https://modavmode.ru
Абсолютно стильные события мира fashion.
Актуальные эвенты лучших подуимов.
Модные дома, бренды, haute couture.
Лучшее место для стильныех людей.
https://miramoda.ru
Абсолютно свежие новости моды.
Все мероприятия мировых подуимов.
Модные дома, бренды, haute couture.
Новое место для трендовых хайпбистов.
https://urban-moda.ru/
Самые стильные новости индустрии.
Исчерпывающие новости самых влиятельных подуимов.
Модные дома, торговые марки, гедонизм.
Приятное место для модных хайпбистов.
https://sofiamoda.ru
Несомненно стильные новинки мировых подиумов.
Все события известнейших подуимов.
Модные дома, торговые марки, haute couture.
Новое место для трендовых людей.
https://fashionsecret.ru
Абсолютно важные новинки индустрии.
Абсолютно все эвенты мировых подуимов.
Модные дома, бренды, гедонизм.
Самое приятное место для трендовых хайпбистов.
https://worldsfashion.ru/
You really make it seem really easy along with
your presentation however I to find this matter to be
really one thing which I believe I would never understand.
It seems too complex and very vast for me.
I am taking a look ahead in your next post,
I will try to get the grasp of it! Escape room lista
I want to to thank you for this good read!! I absolutely enjoyed every
bit of it. I’ve got you bookmarked to look at new things you post
mexico pharmacies prescription drugs: cmq pharma mexican pharmacy – mexican pharmacy
buying prescription drugs in mexico online
https://cmqpharma.online/# reputable mexican pharmacies online
mexico drug stores pharmacies
trustworthy canadian pharmacy canadapharmacyonline legit reputable canadian online pharmacies
legitimate canadian pharmacy online: best canadian online pharmacy – canadian pharmacies
http://indiapharmast.com/# best online pharmacy india
mexican rx online: mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs – reputable mexican pharmacies online
https://canadapharmast.com/# canadianpharmacyworld com
canadian pharmacy in canada reliable canadian pharmacy canadian pharmacy prices
cheapest online pharmacy india: india online pharmacy – Online medicine home delivery
northwest canadian pharmacy: canada drugs online – canadian pharmacy 1 internet online drugstore
online pharmacy india reputable indian pharmacies indian pharmacy paypal
mail order pharmacy india: top 10 online pharmacy in india – top 10 online pharmacy in india
online shopping pharmacy india: indianpharmacy com – indian pharmacy online
https://canadapharmast.online/# pharmacies in canada that ship to the us
pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa: buying from online mexican pharmacy – medicine in mexico pharmacies
mail order pharmacy india Online medicine order best online pharmacy india
buying from canadian pharmacies: legitimate canadian mail order pharmacy – canadian pharmacy uk delivery
п»їbest mexican online pharmacies: mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs – medicine in mexico pharmacies
canadian 24 hour pharmacy: precription drugs from canada – canadian pharmacy meds
https://foruspharma.com/# medication from mexico pharmacy
canadian pharmacy tampa online pharmacy canada canadian pharmacy scam
best mail order pharmacy canada global pharmacy canada canada ed drugs
https://foruspharma.com/# best online pharmacies in mexico
You ought to take part in a contest for one of the best blogs online. I most certainly will recommend this site!
buy prescription drugs from india: world pharmacy india – top 10 online pharmacy in india
best online pharmacy india: top 10 online pharmacy in india – indianpharmacy com
doxycycline 100 cost: cost of doxycycline australia – doxycycline 100mg cost
https://doxycyclinedelivery.pro/# doxycycline capsules 50mg 100mg
paxlovid generic п»їpaxlovid Paxlovid over the counter
http://clomiddelivery.pro/# how to buy clomid without rx
http://ciprodelivery.pro/# cipro for sale
where buy clomid without insurance cost clomid without a prescription get clomid no prescription
doxycycline 100mg best buy: doxycycline 25mg – doxycycline 50mg
order clomid without a prescription: can i order clomid tablets – can i buy clomid
https://amoxildelivery.pro/# buy amoxicillin 500mg online
Having read this I believed it was extremely enlightening. I appreciate you spending some time and effort to put this article together. I once again find myself personally spending a lot of time both reading and commenting. But so what, it was still worth it!
http://ciprodelivery.pro/# buy cipro online without prescription
where can i get amoxicillin 500 mg: amoxicillin 500mg buy online uk – amoxicillin 250 mg
http://paxloviddelivery.pro/# paxlovid pill
amoxicillin 500 mg online amoxicillin over the counter in canada amoxicillin generic brand
http://paxloviddelivery.pro/# paxlovid pill
how can i get clomid without insurance buying generic clomid price where can i get generic clomid no prescription
doxycycline 75 mg price: doxycycline 20 mg india – doxycycline usa pharmacy
https://paxloviddelivery.pro/# Paxlovid over the counter
Howdy, I think your site may be having web browser compatibility problems. Whenever I take a look at your blog in Safari, it looks fine but when opening in Internet Explorer, it’s got some overlapping issues. I just wanted to provide you with a quick heads up! Apart from that, wonderful website.
Paxlovid buy online: paxlovid cost without insurance – paxlovid covid
https://clomiddelivery.pro/# order clomid without dr prescription
buy cipro: ciprofloxacin – ciprofloxacin order online
https://paxloviddelivery.pro/# paxlovid pharmacy
buy clomid can i purchase clomid price can i order cheap clomid
https://paxloviddelivery.pro/# paxlovid for sale
paxlovid india paxlovid cost without insurance paxlovid cost without insurance
doxycycline over the counter south africa: doxycycline 600 mg – doxycycline 200mg price in india
https://amoxildelivery.pro/# cost of amoxicillin prescription
http://paxloviddelivery.pro/# paxlovid price
buy cipro: cipro pharmacy – buy cipro online canada
https://amoxildelivery.pro/# amoxicillin 500mg prescription
paxlovid pharmacy paxlovid cost without insurance paxlovid price
generic amoxicillin: amoxicillin 500mg price canada – amoxicillin capsules 250mg
http://doxycyclinedelivery.pro/# doxycycline 400 mg daily
doxycycline 50 mg tablets price 20 doxycycline doxycycline hydrochloride
http://paxloviddelivery.pro/# paxlovid cost without insurance
amoxicillin 500mg price: amoxicillin 500 mg price – amoxicillin script
http://amoxildelivery.pro/# buy amoxicillin from canada
can i get cheap clomid prices: can you buy clomid for sale – where can i get generic clomid without rx
https://doxycyclinedelivery.pro/# doxycycline 100mg price in india
how can i get clomid tablets generic clomid pill where can i buy clomid pills
http://clomiddelivery.pro/# generic clomid pills
how to buy cheap clomid without prescription cost clomid cost of cheap clomid without a prescription
http://amoxildelivery.pro/# amoxicillin brand name
doxycycline hyclate 100 mg cap: doxycycline capsule 100mg price – doxycycline prescription
doxycycline 150mg pill: doxycycline 100mg online – buy doxycycline 40 mg
https://clomiddelivery.pro/# buy clomid without rx
http://doxycyclinedelivery.pro/# doxycycline 50
http://amoxildelivery.pro/# how to get amoxicillin
where can i buy cipro online ciprofloxacin buy ciprofloxacin
cipro for sale: п»їcipro generic – where can i buy cipro online
http://doxycyclinedelivery.pro/# doxycycline tablets 100mg
where to buy cipro online: buy cipro online canada – ciprofloxacin 500mg buy online
http://ciprodelivery.pro/# ciprofloxacin 500 mg tablet price
I’d like to thank you for the efforts you have put in penning this site. I am hoping to check out the same high-grade blog posts from you later on as well. In truth, your creative writing abilities has motivated me to get my own website now 😉
http://doxycyclinedelivery.pro/# average cost of doxycycline
can i purchase clomid without rx can i buy cheap clomid for sale where can i buy clomid without a prescription
cipro online no prescription in the usa: cipro for sale – ciprofloxacin over the counter
http://ciprodelivery.pro/# buy ciprofloxacin over the counter
https://clomiddelivery.pro/# how to get clomid for sale
can i purchase generic clomid pills: where can i buy clomid – where to get generic clomid price
Paxlovid buy online: Paxlovid buy online – paxlovid pharmacy